As the Indonesian government plans to increase the import of live cattle to stabilize domestic beef prices, a wave of concern is spreading across the country’s farming communities. Local cattle farmers say the move threatens their livelihoods and could destabilize the already fragile rural livestock economy.
⚠️ The Government’s Plan
In a bid to ensure food security and meet rising consumer demand, the Ministry of Agriculture recently announced an initiative to import tens of thousands of live cattle from Australia and other countries. The goal is to reduce beef prices in urban markets, especially ahead of religious holidays when demand spikes.
According to officials, imported cattle will help fill the supply gap, reduce inflation on meat products, and offer consumers more affordable prices. However, this economic strategy has sparked unease in rural regions.
🐄 Farmers Sound the Alarm
For small-scale cattle farmers in provinces like East Nusa Tenggara, West Java, and South Sulawesi, the decision feels like a direct threat.
“We are already struggling with feed prices, diseases, and limited market access. Now imported cattle will flood the market and push prices even lower,” said Budi Santoso, a cattle breeder in Central Java.
Farmers fear that the sudden influx of cheaper, often larger and faster-growing imported breeds could outcompete their native cattle, which are typically raised on smaller farms with traditional methods.
📉 Market Impact: Price Wars and Oversupply
Over the past few years, local farmers have seen prices fluctuate unpredictably. With the entry of imported cattle, experts warn that a market imbalance could occur. A price war could hurt not only smallholders but also local slaughterhouses and cooperatives.
“There’s a risk of oversupply. When there’s too much beef in the market, everyone loses—especially the farmers who can’t compete on price or production volume,” said Dewi Rahayu, an agricultural economist from Gadjah Mada University.
🌿 Local Breeds at Risk
Another growing concern is the possible decline of local cattle breeds, such as Bali cattle, which are well-adapted to Indonesia’s climate and terrain. If the market shifts heavily in favor of imported breeds, local genetic diversity could suffer, along with traditional cattle-rearing practices passed down through generations.
🧩 Looking for Balance
Farmers are urging the government to reconsider the scale and speed of imports. Many are calling for:
- Protective regulations to safeguard local producers
- Subsidies or incentives for local cattle development
- Long-term investment in feed supply, veterinary care, and infrastructure
- Clear labeling between imported and local beef in markets
🗣️ A Call for Dialogue
While the government aims to protect consumers, experts stress the need for inclusive policy-making that involves all stakeholders—especially the rural communities most affected.
“We need solutions that help both consumers and producers. A one-sided import strategy could cause long-term harm to our local cattle industry,” said Rini Hartono, a livestock development advocate.
🇮🇩 The Bigger Picture
Indonesia’s push for food security is understandable in a globalized world facing climate disruptions and supply chain issues. However, the well-being of its millions of rural farmers must also remain a priority.
As policymakers weigh their next steps, the voices of Indonesia’s farmers grow louder—calling not for protectionism, but for fairness, balance, and sustainability in the nation’s food system.
Have thoughts or personal experiences about cattle farming in Indonesia? Share your story in the comments or contact us to be featured in a follow-up piece.